MEMBERSHIP CALL TO ACTION ON ASOR’S NAME CHANGE
October 6, 2020
Dear Fellow 17ԹMembers:
I wrote you all in late August with the exciting news that ASOR’s Board of Trustees had voted to remove the word “Oriental” from ASOR’s name. Now I write with an update and a timeline for the next steps, which will include town halls with the membership and two votes over the next month.
All organizations have moments in their history when a transformative change needs to be made. Recognizing ASOR’s 120-year history of leadership, ASOR’s Board of Trustees voted unanimously to remove the word “Oriental” from our name as the first step to ensure that we took a stand against culturally offensive language. Words matter.
The next step requires a ratification of this change and the Board’s recommendation on ASOR’s new name by a majority of the 17Թmembership. You will be asked to choose between two 17Թacronyms: the American ǴDZof Overseas Research or the American Society of Overseas Research. After the choice is made between “society” and “schools,” we will need a final ratification vote by the membership in order to legally amend ASOR’s Articles of Incorporation.
Below is a summary of how the Board arrived at this decision.
The Ad Hoc Committee on the name change (AHC) has been working since January to consider all alternatives, including new acronyms, descriptive language, and a myriad of other options. Their work included two polls of the membership.
After a great deal of discussion and endless hours of trying to find the best answers, AHC recommended that two names be considered: AARCHE, Association for Archaeological Research, Cultural Heritage, and Education and one of two names using the 17Թacronym, either the American Schools of Overseas Research or the American Society of Overseas Research.
After the AHC submitted its final report, the discussion of the full Board in consultation with the AHC focused on whether the new name should retain the 17Թacronym or be completely different, which opened up the opportunity to solve some of the inherent constraints of the 17Թacronym. In AARCHE’s favor were its freshness and the fact that it reflects better the breadth of ASOR’s current work, particularly in cultural heritage. Against it are its somewhat unwieldy length, unfortunate acronym for a renamed BASOR—”BAARCHE”—and its lack of popularity in the July poll of the membership.
With the lack of a membership mandate for AARCHE or any wholesale change in name, the Board turned to the costs of abandoning the 17Թacronym, both tangible and intangible. Our Executive Director estimates that the necessary changes in our now large website presence would cost between $50,000 and $100,000, amounts which do not include a new branding program. Library subscriptions to the renamed “BAARCHE” would undoubtedly drop. The value of the well-known brand would be lost, which our Development Committee believes would have significant adverse effects on fundraising.
In the Board discussion of the AHC recommendations, various members noted that neither of the choices satisfied the desire of 70.3% of the membership in the March poll that the name reflect the geographical scope of ASOR’s work. Accepting that ASOR’s scope will always change and grow, it seemed prudent to keep the name as simple as possible given all that is required legally to change it, but include a yet to be determined geographical tag line below the name as a descriptor.
After lengthy discussion with the AHC, the Board voted 20-3 to put only the two 17Թacronyms, the American Schools of Overseas Research or the American Society of Overseas Research, up for a membership vote.
What’s next? A membership vote on the name change.
-
- Two Zoom town hall meetings with the membership in October.
- A vote on the two names in late October.
- A vote on ratification of the winning name in November.
As always, you can contact me directly at president@asor.org with questions or concerns. Thank you for helping our organization take this vital step into a brighter future for us all.
Best regards,
Sharon Herbert
17ԹPresident